Being Afraid Gets in the Way (Twenty-fifth Sunday after Pentecost)

Sermons on YouTube…

Many of the biblical readings which are assigned for this time in the church year are readings which focus on the “end times.” And often, they conclude with scenes of reckoning, judgement and sometimes punishment for those who didn’t do what they were supposed to do.

Honestly, many of them are scary.  And this has often led many people – including biblical commentators and preachers who should know better – to interpret them as meaning: “Jesus is coming – so be afraid!  Be very afraid!  If you were a little more afraid, maybe you would straighten up and fly right!”

The problem, though, is that being afraid is never the point of any of these readings – especially these parables.  And today’s parable of the talents is a key example.

Jesus tells a story where there are three slaves entrusted with a number of “talents.”  A “talent” is an amount of money equal to about 20 years of regular wages.  Even one talent was an enormous sum.  And these three slaves – who would probably have been town treasurers who were captured in war – knew how to manage money and were entrusted with the money “to each according to his ability.”

So all of them knew what to do.  All of them were capable.  All of them had plenty of time and opportunity. And all of them knew the master would come back and expect them to have done something with the talents.

But one doesn’t do it.  He buries the talent in the ground, and when the master comes back and asks what the heck was wrong with him, he replies, “I was afraid.”

He was really afraid!  In fact, this is the problem – it wasn’t that he wasn’t afraid enough, it was that he was too afraid. And his fear got in the way of doing his job.

Now honestly, sometimes a little bit of fear is a good thing.  Fear can make me look before I leap.  And fear can alert me to an actual danger in my life.

But too much fear can also stop us in our tracks.  It can get in the way.  It can prevent us from seeing opportunity, envisioning new possibilities and taking action that results in us and others experiencing joy. 

And that’s what happens to the guy with one talent. He was just too afraid. Maybe, he was afraid of:

  • Loss – after all, he had a “fiduciary responsibility” to look after somebody else’s money.  But apparently, the fear of loss was so great that he didn’t even employ the “risk-averse” strategy of putting the talent in the bank so it could at least earn interest.  The fear of loss was so great that it blinded him to even the most modest opportunity…
  • Making a mistake – in the story, Jesus doesn’t elaborate on what a “good investment strategy” looks like; but it’s clear that everyone faced choices that could have turned out to be mistakes; probably, in the course of their trading, the other two made mistakes.  But they took that risk and kept on trying.  The guy with the one talent, on the other hand, was so paralyzed by the fear of making a mistake that he couldn’t envision the opportunities that the other two could…
  • Judgement – after all, he says that he was afraid of being judged by the master.  The irony is that he was so afraid of being judged for doing a bad job that he did the very thing that any objective financial steward would know was a bad job…

So, this parable is NOT intended to scare folks into being so afraid of God’s judgement that they get off their butts and do what God wants them to do. After all, the guy with the one talent is already plenty afraid right from the start.  In fact, it’s too much fear that gets in the way of being a good steward.  It’s fear that prevents him from seeing opportunity and envisioning new possibilities. And it’s fear that stops him from doing something meaningful and worthwhile.

Being afraid is counterproductive.  Rather, Jesus instead wants us to experience:

  • New life when we face the fear of loss – this is, after all, what the Resurrection is all about…; the greatest loss we face is the loss of life itself; but often, when we get too focused on what we’ve lost or might lose, we miss out on seeing new opportunities that God is placing before us today; this was true in Jesus’ day, and I know it’s sometimes true in my life as well…
  • Forgiveness when we face the fear of making a mistake – which is the point of one of my favorite Luther quotes, “Sin boldly…(but believe in Christ more boldly still)”…; there simply is no way to go through life an avoid mistakes, even when we’re trying; forgiveness isn’t the proclamation that mistakes don’t matter, but that mistakes don’t have the last word; and if that’s the case, then we can live beyond our mistakes and see new possibilities that we can’t experience while we’re hung up on trying not to make a new mistake…
  • Grace and mercy when we face the fear of even being judged by ourselves – after all, Jesus gets in trouble with good “religious” people for NOT judging outcasts and “sinners”…; there are those who think that fear of judgement can make people into better folks (certainly, there were scribes and Pharisees in Jesus’ day who thought that); but fear of the judgement of God, or even fear of the judgement of our own regrets, doesn’t often change us for the better. Clearly, it didn’t for the guy with 1 talent. In fact, it just robs us of experiencing the joy that really can change us and give us hope and vision for a new day…

Jesus reminds us in this parable that God has given us, and will yet give us, more opportunities than we can image.  Jesus reminds us in this parable that as long as we live, we have ever new possibilities to experience and share God’s gifts.  And Jesus reminds us in this parable that what God really wants is for us to experience his own joy as we live into those opportunities and possibilities.

But fear can get in the way.  It can prevent us from seeing the opportunities, envisioning the possibilities and experiencing the joy.

So when you hear these readings, remember that it’s often being afraid that gets in the way of experiencing God’s gifts and doing what God wants you to do with them. And it’s through many of these parables that Jesus calls us to be alert for how fear can get in the way.  And instead of fear, Jesus calls us to hope in the promise of new life; to trust in the promise of forgiveness; and to use the talents God gives us to live joyfully into God’s promise of grace and mercy.

Amen.